The York City Supporters Trust (YCST) is today publishing its detailed report into the incidents surrounding the Hartlepool vs. York City match on January 27, 2024. This report aims to provide a balanced account of the events, highlighting key issues and offering recommendations to improve the match day experience for supporters and all involved parties.

YCST would like to extend its thanks to Hartlepool United Football Club for their time, openness, and proactive engagement throughout the preparation of this report. Their willingness to address the issues identified and implement changes demonstrates a strong commitment to improving the experience and safety for visiting supporters.

Key Conclusions

  • Call for an Independent Review: The report calls for an independent review of Cleveland Police’s approach to football policing, particularly their use of significant force and confrontational tactics. Proportionality and de-escalation must become priorities in future operations.
  • Better Planning and Communication: Pre-game and post-game plans for supporters require improvement, with clear communication and coordination between police, clubs, and fan groups to ensure safety and reduce tensions.
  • Addressing Issues with Supporter Housing: Crowding in areas of the away section, compounded by inconsistent stewarding, detracted from the match day experience, particularly for disabled supporters. Improvements in crowd management and facilities are essential.
  • Fan Responsibility: Supporters have a crucial role to play in ensuring a positive match day environment by taking responsibility for their actions and showing respect to fellow fans, police, and stewards.

Next Steps

The York City Supporters Trust will:

  • Advocate for an independent review of Cleveland Police’s football policing practices.
  • Work with stakeholders to implement the report’s recommendations and foster safer and more inclusive environment for football supporters.
  • Continue to educate and support fans in understanding their responsibilities and rights at football matches.

The full report, including detailed findings, recommendations, and eyewitness accounts, is now available here. We hope it will serve as a foundation for constructive dialogue and collaboration, ultimately improving safety, fan experiences, and relationships across the football community.

Hartlepool Report Available Here

About York City Supporters’ Trust

Established in 2002, York City Supporters Trust is a not-for-profit Community Benefit Society, regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. We were formed to protect the long-term future of the football club and represent the interests of the fans. We are also 25% shareholders in York City Football Club Ltd.